Holiday Shipping Deadlines

Please note these deadlines are not guaranteed due to areas out of our control such as provider and custom delays. We recommend ordering as quickly as possible to ensure arrival before the holiday.

Domestic United States
Standard December 11, 2020
USPS Priority Mail December 19, 2020
UPS Ground December 15, 2020
UPS 3 Day December 21, 2020
UPS 2 Day December 22, 2020
UPS Next Day December 23, 2020
Standard December 7, 2020
Packet Tracked December 9, 2020
Priority Tracked December 11, 2020
Fedex December 18, 2020

New Era Mystery 59Fifty Fitted Hat



New Era Mystery 59Fifty Fitted Hat


In stock items ship within 1 business day

Are you a risk taker?

If so, these hats probably aren't for you. Ordering a New Era Mystery 59Fifty Fitted Hat is pretty much a no-risk investment. Well at least for the geeky, nerdy type who likes fitted hats with flat brims. You see, these hats are all certified awesome bestsellers that we've moved out of our sales rotation to make room for newer styles.

If you're a fan of sure-things, safe bets, and deeply discounted mystery fun than place your order now! Featuring your favorite heroes and villains from across Marvel, DC, Star Wars, and various pop-culture phenomenons.

NOTE: If you are ordering more than one mystery hat our staff will do their best to ensure you do not receive a duplicate design. 


More Details

  • Product Brands:
  • Superherostuff,
  • DC Heroes And Justice League,
  • Marvel Heroes And Avengers,
  • Star Wars
  • Product Category:
  • Clothing & Apparel,
  • Headwear,
  • Hats & Caps
  • SKU: hatneweramystery5950

Reviews of New Era Mystery 59Fifty Fitted Hat

5.0 (Based on 10 reviews)
Adrian Montanez
PR, United States

OK I wasn't expecting much just an old out of stock hat. But what I got was amazing. I was really surprised. I love the hat.

Submitted 3 years ago
Luis Martinez
CA, United States

It was a pleasant surprise and fit well.

Submitted 2 years ago
Sean Adams
SFK, United Kingdom

Brilliant idea great value hat too

Submitted 2 years ago
Kyle Haines
PA, United States

Always something i wanted which is GREAT!!!!!

Submitted 2 years ago
John Blood
AZ, United States

I rolled the dice on a mystery hat, and and got a sweet Star Wars cap!!

Submitted 1 year ago
ON, Canada

Got a cool Wonder Woman hat that I will never wear as it is too tight and too flashy. Unlucky I guess.

Submitted 1 year ago
Angela Dominguez
NV, United States

The hat is very nice and the color is great.

Submitted 11 months ago
Logan Howlettt

First of all the quality of the hat is great. New Era products are some of the best and it's especially great to have a vendor that carries the New Era fitted hats sporting cool logos from geek culture. Regular snapbacks don't fit me well so I love the 59-50 fitted hats. Maybe a misread of the item description on my part, but the hat I ended up with is a hat that's currently on clearance, so interesting how that happened, but I guess discounted hats are technically no longer in rotation? (So just an FYI to those thinking of buying that you might end up with one of those). Overall though I'm happy with the quality of the product and this is definitely where I'd buy another fitted hat from. (Some more Star Wars hats for the different groups in that universe would be cool to see!)

Submitted 3 months ago
Clinton Pawsey
ON, Canada

If you like superheroes then this is the one for you

Submitted 3 months ago
ivan cello
JK, Indonesia


Submitted 2 months ago

Are you a risk taker?

$5 Mystery Gift

For just $5 bucks add a little intrigue to your order with our Mystery Gift.